014- When the Walls Come Tumbling Down”: A Cautionary Tale of Structural Failure on My Doorstep

Introduction

One quiet Thursday evening, I was sitting at home, diligently working through a few lingering tasks, when my evening peace was shattered by a thunderous crash. This wasn’t your average domestic thud. No, this was a full-bodied, echoing clatter that immediately had me upright and on alert. The kind of sound that makes you instinctively mutter, “Well, that can’t be good."
​
At first, I assumed a vehicle must’ve veered off the narrow lane that winds through our quiet countryside hamlet. But as I stepped outside, it quickly became clear that the chaos had occurred far closer to home. The noise, reminiscent of a tonne of bricks being hurled from a great height, had in fact come from next door. My neighbour’s garage had entirely collapsed—front and side walls reduced to rubble, the timber and slate roof in splinters, and the poor car inside looking like it had narrowly survived a war zone.
​

A Slow-Motion Collapse: Signs We Ignore

Now, as someone who deals with buildings and their shortcomings on a daily basis, I’d love to say I was completely surprised. But truthfully, I wasn’t. I’d been watching that garage’s slow decline over the past several weeks, quietly observing its increasingly noticeable lean and sag. The mortar joints were gaping, timbers warping, and I’d even made a passing comment to my neighbour that the structure looked, in technical terms, “a bit dodgy.” Unfortunately, structures don’t always afford you a generous grace period once they start to fail.
This little incident was a stark reminder that while we, as building professionals, spend our days identifying and analysing structural failings in commercial or public buildings, issues closer to home can escalate just as dramatically. We are often exposed to decayed brickwork, sagging roofs, and questionable DIY extensions, but there’s something sobering about a collapse occurring quite literally on your doorstep.

What happened here wasn’t a freak accident. Buildings very rarely fail without warning. In fact, most of them try to tell us what’s wrong before things go horribly wrong. That’s the key point. Buildings don’t collapse silently or instantly. They crack, creak, shift, and lean. They give you clues—sometimes subtle, sometimes glaring—long before gravity takes its final toll.
In this particular case, there are several likely reasons why the garage failed. One of the most common causes is change in ground condition. Subsidence, for instance, can cause previously stable ground to shift, especially in clay-rich soils where moisture content varies seasonally. Heave is another culprit, where the ground swells due to increased moisture or root removal. Either of these conditions can throw off a building’s equilibrium and cause walls to lean or buckle under their own weight. And once that balance is upset, it doesn’t take much for collapse to follow.
Buildings also fail when their foundations are poorly constructed or insufficient for the loads they bear. If the original structure was erected on shallow footings or with materials not suited to long-term support, deterioration becomes inevitable. Water ingress plays a major role too—once moisture seeps into structural elements, it can rot timber, corrode steel, or degrade masonry, slowly compromising the integrity of the whole structure. And let’s not forget overloading. Adding heavy new elements to an ageing or lightly-built structure—be it storage, plant equipment, or even an additional floor—can tip the scales quite literally.

What’s frustrating is that these issues are usually visible. In the weeks leading up to the garage collapse, the tell-tale signs were all there: the widening cracks, the slumped roofline, the increasingly crooked angle of the walls. But because the building was small, non-habitable, and perhaps not considered "important," those signs were either missed or ignored.
It’s also important to consider the human element—negligence or lack of maintenance. Even the best-built structures can fail if they aren’t cared for. Roofs require regular checking, gutters need clearing, pointing must be maintained, and any signs of rot or damp should be tackled quickly. Ageing buildings especially demand more frequent attention, and yet it’s common for owners to adopt a “wait and see” approach. Unfortunately, when it comes to structural stability, waiting often leads to very expensive seeing.
​
Now, you might wonder who’s responsible when a building fails and causes damage—be it to property, vehicles, or heaven forbid, people. The answer is: the owner. As a property owner, you have a legal duty of care not only to yourself and your tenants, but to your neighbours and the public. If a wall collapses and injures someone, or causes damage next door, you could find yourself liable. That’s not only a financial risk—it’s a moral and legal one too.

Don’t Wait Until the Cracks Turn to Chaos:

​That’s why we always recommend that any suspected structural issues are investigated promptly. Our surveying practice offers initial assessments to help you understand the extent of a problem. If there’s cause for concern, we bring in structural engineers to carry out a deeper analysis using precise tools, calculations, and inspections to determine what’s wrong and how to fix it. It’s always better to catch these issues early, when repairs are manageable, rather than waiting until a building is unsalvageable—or dangerous.

Take Cracks Seriously—They Might Be Speaking to You:
​

Buildings fail for many reasons—subsidence, poor foundations, water damage, overloading, neglect—but in almost all cases, the signs are visible if you know what to look for. Cracks, leaning, sagging, and damp are not just aesthetic issues—they’re red flags. And while not every wonky outbuilding is about to collapse, a quick professional look can give peace of mind or prompt action before disaster strikes.
​
In the end, the garage collapse next door was a dramatic reminder of the very work I do every day. It was also a wake-up call to homeowners everywhere: even in a sleepy hamlet, structural failure isn’t some distant threat. It’s very real, and sometimes very close to home. So, take those creaks and cracks seriously. And if in doubt, call someone who knows what they’re looking at. Preferably before your car ends up under a pile of slate and bricks.

​About the Author

Joe Marshall BSc (Hons)
Building Surveyor and Director of Silver Teal Ltd

With an expansive career throughout London and Southeast England. Joe brings a wealth of expertise to the Silver Teal Workspace. His extensive experience in both public and private sectors, notably in social housing and emergency services, has honed his proficiency in building pathology and the overall built environment. Joe's academic achievements are highlighted by his 1st Class Honours degree in Building Surveying.

As a director, he is a fervent advocate for nurturing young talent and fostering industry growth. Joe is committed to propelling Silver Teal Workspace forward with his visionary leadership.

If you would like a complimentary discussion with Joe feel free to get in touch

📞 0208 103 4842
✉️ [email protected]